M57, The Ring Nebula

This photo is for context and shows the entire 2" field of the 4 x 5 camera on the 8", F5. North is up and Beta Lyrae is the bright star on the right and Gamma on the left. M57 is the non-descript white smudge between the two, in the center of the photo.

The following images were taken with the 8" (left) and the 10" (center) and 16" right. The 8 and 10 inch are photos on hypered Techpan and the 16" is a CCD image. The 8" photo is actually an enlargement of the "context" photo above.

An amazing thing happened one night while experimenting with my new CCD camera. It was too late to do any serious imaging so I just pointed the scope at the Ring Nebula (M57) to see what my new CCD camera could do and I "discovered" a faint smudge just to the North of it in the same field. A quick study of the charts indicated that it was not a comet but a very faint galaxy that I had never noticed before. Even though the Ring is probably the most photographed object in the sky, it is so much brighter, that the galaxy is not visible in images optimized to bring out detail in M57.

The next night I set out to get a good image of the galaxy along with M57 in the same field for reference. I took a single 20 minute exposure and after processing it the next day, I went looking for other images but found nothing comparable until I got to the Palomar Schmidt photo (DSS). My joy was unbounded when I found star after star on my image that I could not see on the Palomar image.

It is truly mind boggling that a modest amateur telescope with the latest electronic technology can do today, what the greatest telescopes of only a decade or two ago could do. I invite you to compare the two images below. The only edge the Palomar image has is that it seems to be more sensitive to the emission wavelength of the halo around M57 than the CCD camera. I would also presume that something, no doubt has been lost, between the original plate and the DSS image.

It should be noted that seeing "star after star" is not is not for the casual observer. You might have to move the images off line to optimize the contrast and brightness for your particular viewer. Furthermore, it takes a trained eye to see the very faintest stars on images and make useful comparisons. Finally, my image was re-scaled smaller so the two images could be presented side by side on a web page for easy comparison and of course, both images have been compressed to save bandwidth. I have no clue as to why my image is brighter on the right side.

Just for references, the Ring lies at a distance of about 1500 light years and IC 1296 at about 320 million light years. It's a bit like lining your thumb up with a distant mountain.

The Ring Nebula

And finally we have the mandatory color image of the Ring. This was a 1 minute exposure with the MX5C camera through the 16" telescope.

~ [Return to top of page]

JSP homepage